Games with unreliable narrators have emerged as a captivating storytelling device, blurring the lines between fiction and reality. By presenting narratives through characters whose perceptions are distorted, these games challenge players to question the truth and engage in deeper analysis of the unfolding events. This article delves into the concept of unreliable narrators in video games, exploring their impact on gameplay, player experience, and the evolution of narrative techniques in the gaming industry.
Understanding Unreliable Narrators in Video Games
An unreliable narrator is a character whose credibility has been seriously compromised. In literature and film, this technique has been used to create suspense and surprise. In video games, it serves a similar purpose but also adds an interactive layer. Players are not just passive recipients of the story; they are active participants who must navigate through layers of deception and misdirection.
The unreliable narrator in games can take various forms:
-
Amnesiac Protagonists: Characters who have lost their memory, leading to distorted recollections of past events.
-
Manipulative AIs: Artificial intelligences that deceive the player for various reasons, often to serve their own agenda.
-
Psychologically Unstable Characters: Individuals whose mental state affects their perception of reality, leading to unreliable accounts of events.
-
Multiple Perspectives: Narratives presented from different viewpoints, each with its own biases and limitations.
This narrative technique not only enhances storytelling but also deepens player engagement, prompting them to question the nature of truth within the game world.
Notable Games Featuring Unreliable Narrators
The Stanley Parable
In The Stanley Parable, players control Stanley, a man who discovers that his colleagues have mysteriously vanished. The game is guided by a narrator who provides commentary on Stanley’s actions. However, the narrator’s reliability is questionable, as players can choose to ignore his instructions, leading to various endings that challenge the concept of choice and free will in gaming.
BioShock Infinite
BioShock Infinite follows Booker DeWitt, a man tasked with rescuing a woman named Elizabeth from the floating city of Columbia. Throughout the game, Booker’s recollections and perceptions are called into question, revealing that his understanding of events is deeply flawed. The narrative explores themes of memory, identity, and the nature of reality, making players reconsider what they know about the protagonist and the world around him.
Metal Gear Solid 2: Sons of Liberty
In Metal Gear Solid 2, players begin by controlling Solid Snake, only to later take on the role of Raiden. Raiden’s commanding officer, known as The Colonel, provides guidance throughout the mission. However, it is later revealed that The Colonel is an AI, manipulating Raiden’s perceptions and actions, leading to a profound commentary on control, freedom, and the nature of reality.
Final Fantasy VII
In Final Fantasy VII, players follow Cloud Strife, a mercenary who joins a group fighting against a megacorporation. As the story unfolds, it becomes apparent that Cloud’s memories are not entirely accurate, and his identity is not what it seems. This revelation adds depth to the narrative, exploring themes of identity, memory, and self-perception.
Uncharted 4: A Thief’s End
In Uncharted 4, Nathan Drake is led to believe that his brother Sam was freed from prison by a crime boss named Hector Alcazar. However, it is later disclosed that this story was fabricated, and Sam’s escape was orchestrated by the antagonist Rafe Adler. This twist challenges the player’s understanding of the narrative and character motivations.
Silent Hill 2
In Silent Hill 2, players control James Sunderland, who receives a letter from his deceased wife, prompting him to visit the eerie town of Silent Hill. As the story progresses, it becomes clear that James’s understanding of events is distorted by his guilt and grief, leading to a narrative that blurs the lines between reality and illusion.
The Psychological Appeal of Being Deceived
The appeal of unreliable narrators often lies in the psychological thrill of being misled and then discovering the truth. For players, it becomes a kind of intellectual puzzle—piecing together conflicting bits of information, interpreting hidden symbolism, and challenging their assumptions. This dynamic fosters critical thinking and emotional engagement, as players must navigate both the game world and the character’s internal world. The revelation that the narrator has been misleading (intentionally or not) delivers a strong emotional payoff, often leading to shock, empathy, or deep reflection.
Narrative Misdirection as a Design Philosophy
For many developers, using an unreliable narrator isn’t just a plot twist—it’s a core design philosophy. The storytelling is crafted in layers, where the player’s journey is tied to gradually peeling back falsehoods to arrive at the truth. Games like Amnesia: The Dark Descent or Hellblade: Senua’s Sacrifice blend environmental storytelling, audio cues, and disjointed narration to simulate mental illness or trauma, making the unreliability of the protagonist’s viewpoint an essential gameplay feature rather than a gimmick.
This type of narrative structure can also act as a metaphor for real-life issues—trauma, PTSD, guilt, or fragmented identity—giving games a new platform for emotional and psychological storytelling that resonates deeply with players.
The Impact of Unreliable Narrators on Gameplay and Player Experience
The use of unreliable narrators in video games significantly enhances the storytelling experience by:
-
Encouraging Critical Thinking: Players must analyze and question the information presented, leading to a more engaged and thoughtful gaming experience.
-
Enhancing Emotional Impact: Revelations about the narrator’s unreliability can evoke strong emotional responses, deepening the player’s connection to the story.
-
Increasing Replayability: The complexity introduced by unreliable narrators often leads to multiple interpretations of the story, encouraging players to revisit the game to uncover different facets of the narrative.
-
Fostering Immersion: By challenging the player’s perceptions, unreliable narrators can create a more immersive and thought-provoking gaming experience.
Future Possibilities: AI and Player-Specific Narratives
With advancements in artificial intelligence and machine learning, the concept of unreliable narrators may evolve into even more personalized experiences. Future games might adapt the story in real time based on player behavior, decisions, or even biometric feedback. The narrator could learn how a player thinks and actively deceive them in smarter, more personalized ways—creating a kind of dynamic deception where no two players experience the same story.
Imagine a game where the narrator adapts to your play style, praises your mistakes, hides important information based on your choices, or even gaslights you into doubting your previous actions. These types of mechanics could push the boundaries of what storytelling in video games can achieve, ushering in a new era of emotionally intelligent interactive fiction.
Conclusion
Games with unreliable narrators represent a sophisticated evolution in interactive storytelling. By manipulating the player’s perception of truth, these games create narratives that are not only engaging but also intellectually stimulating. As the gaming industry continues to explore and experiment with narrative techniques, the role of unreliable narrators is likely to expand, offering players even more complex and compelling stories to experience.
FAQs
What is an unreliable narrator in video games?
An unreliable narrator in video games is a character who presents a biased, distorted, or misleading version of the story. This can be due to memory loss, intentional deception, mental instability, or limited knowledge. The player must often decipher the truth from the lies or omissions presented, adding a layer of mystery and engagement to the narrative.
Why do developers use unreliable narrators in games?
Game developers use unreliable narrators to deepen storytelling, create plot twists, and engage players on a psychological level. This technique forces players to think critically, reevaluate events, and question what’s real within the game world, ultimately making for a more immersive and layered experience.
Are there any risks to using unreliable narrators in storytelling?
Yes, if not handled carefully, unreliable narrators can confuse or frustrate players. A poorly executed narrative twist can feel like a cheap trick rather than a clever reveal. To succeed, the game must balance ambiguity with clues that allow players to piece things together in hindsight, maintaining trust in the storytelling process even when the narrator is deceptive.
Can an unreliable narrator exist in multiplayer or online games?
While most commonly found in single-player story-driven titles, the concept of an unreliable narrator can be adapted for multiplayer settings. For instance, in games with roleplay or faction-based narratives, misinformation or propaganda spread by in-game characters or factions can act as a form of unreliable narration, influencing player decisions and alliances.
What are some other examples of games with unreliable narrators not mentioned above?
-
Spec Ops: The Line – A psychological shooter that explores the horrors of war, with the protagonist’s perception of reality gradually deteriorating.
-
What Remains of Edith Finch – Some of the family stories are presented through the subjective lens of the narrators, which may not be grounded in truth.
-
Call of Juarez: Gunslinger – The protagonist recounts exaggerated tales of his life, often changing the narrative mid-story, which is then reflected in the gameplay.
How do unreliable narrators affect game replayability?
Games with unreliable narrators often encourage multiple playthroughs. On the first play, players experience the twist and begin to question the narrative. On subsequent plays, they can search for hidden clues, alternative interpretations, or paths that reveal more about the truth, adding considerable depth and value to the game.
Is the use of unreliable narrators a recent trend in video games?
While not entirely new, the use of unreliable narrators has become more prevalent in modern game design, particularly with the rise of narrative-driven indie games and complex AAA storytelling. Advances in technology and game design now allow developers to explore nuanced psychological themes that support this storytelling technique more effectively than in earlier generations of gaming.